Boatwork Review IndexIndependent reviews of MarineMax dealerships

← All locations

MarineMax Sarasota

4.2114 reviewsSarasota, FL

1601 Ken Thompson Pkwy, Sarasota, FL 34236

Summary by Boatwork

Based on 114 Google reviews

MarineMax Sarasota receives consistent praise for salesperson attentiveness and product knowledge but faces recurring complaints about slow service response times and incomplete diagnostics.

What customers praise

  • Sales reps spend unhurried time with customers across

    he spent a lot of time with us going over the boat and treating us as if we were his customer. No pressure, no B.S.

  • Service staff assist with parts diagnostics and sourcing

    He was able to narrow it down and got the correct part number and even gave the number for a competitor for the part.

  • Sales representatives manage entire purchase process

    Mark took care of everything and we felt comfortable and very happy buying our Boat

Recurring concerns

  • Service requests face multi-week response delays

    It took 6 MONTHS of contacting 3 different service managers before someone returned my call

  • Service staff conduct incomplete diagnostics and charge for

    charged me $511 for the diagnosis. The mobile tech never checked the battery chargers or the GFI outlet.

  • Service turnaround times exceed two months for routine

    running lights don't work-8 weeks for repair-6 weeks to just look at it

Themes extracted by Boatwork from the public Google review corpus for this location. Quotes are short verbatim fragments grounded in real reviews. Refreshed daily.

  • ★★★★★DENNIS LAWSON · 2026-06-07T16:38:55Z

    Our dealership is Marinemax Clearwater, wherein Scott Ledwith is our long time representative. However, the boat we wanted to see learn

  • ★★★★★Budskrilla 2U · 2025-12-01T20:40:12Z

    Excellent customer service. Needed part for older mercury and I wasn't sure if I had the right part number because of different models. He

  • ☆☆☆☆Jonathan Rosenthal · 2026-03-17T14:57:21Z

    I had the worst experience buying this bust from the marina. The salesperson was actually talking about me while I was on hold and then

  • ☆☆☆☆Chris Sang · 2025-10-19T16:14:51Z

    Worst experience with a boat or car dealer in my life time. It took 6 MONTHS of contacting 3 different service managers before someone

  • ★★★★★James Scardelli · 2020-07-23T16:37:47Z

    We have been made to feel like a member of the MarineMax family from the instant we met Josh, Heather, Bob, Bryan and the staff on the

  • ☆☆☆☆Danny Garrido · 2025-05-26T19:57:02Z

    Not crazy about a place that won’t even return your web inquiry “because you didn’t buy your boat from them”. Called because they are

  • ★★☆☆☆Mike Goodman · 2021-01-09T13:00:15Z

    First the good. The staff is first class and hard working. The place is very clean. Location is perfect except during season when getting

  • ★★★★★Penelopesita Titán · 2024-07-19T18:57:23Z

    we are very happy!!! Our Sales Agent was Mark Terres and we can not thank him enough! TOP serious,TOP professional,TOP service and TOP

Short excerpts shown with attribution. Full reviews live on Google Maps — read all reviews for MarineMax Sarasota

Further reading

Boatwork, the publisher of this index, published an independent 2026 analysis of MarineMax covering the company profile, brand portfolio, buying experience, service, and how outcomes vary between individual dealerships — including the Sarasota, FL market.

MarineMax Review 2026 — boatwork.co